Yesterday, I read an article in the New York Times regarding black women’s issue of being obese entitled “Why Black Women are Fat.”
FOUR out of five black women are seriously overweight. One out of four middle-aged black women has diabetes. With $174 billion a year spent on diabetes-related illness in America and obesity quickly overtaking smoking as a cause of cancer deaths, it is past time to try something new.
I reviewed the article looking for more insight and made sure to keep an open mind while reading it. I was taken aback by the author’s claims of why black women are overweight. The reason – we (blacks as a culture) accept being overweight.
What we need is a body-culture revolution in black America. Why? Because too many experts who are involved in the discussion of obesity don’t understand something crucial about black women and fat: many black women are fat because we want to be. ….. Chemically, in its ability to promote disease, black fat may be the same as white fat. Culturally it is not.
The writer discusses her own previous desires to be “thicker” and quotes how many husbands/boyfriends were disappointed when their black woman desired to lose weight for fear they would lose their thickness.
How many middle-aged white women fear their husbands will find them less attractive if their weight drops to less than 200 pounds? I have yet to meet one. But I know many black women whose sane, handsome, successful husbands worry when their women start losing weight. My lawyer husband is one.
Another friend, a woman of color who is a tenured professor, told me that her husband, also a tenured professor and of color, begged her not to lose “the sugar down below” when she embarked on a weight-loss program.
At dinner last night, Whitney and I briefly discussed the article, and we both agreed with part of the writer’s claim. In my conversation with Whitney, I recalled growing up in the hood and pointed out how many of my classmates grandmothers were called “Big Momma” because they were literally big aka obese. Being big was/is acceptable and there was nothing wrong with it.
My Reflections While Growing Up In the “Hood”
After people hit their 20 and 30s, being big or bigger was acceptable and the norm. The only people who were skinny or had a slender frame, were crack heads or kids. Being skinny or slender was looked at as a disease. Everyone wanted and should have bigger butts, breast and thicker thighs. Eating hamhocks, collard greens and sweet potato pie was the prescription for achieving this.
The more you filled out your clothes the “better looking” and acceptable you were considered. One of my best friends in middle school was always being teased for her slenderness and forced to “eat more” because she didn’t look healthy. She was an ideal weight for her height, age and activity level. While she ate, flaming hot Cheetos and chili cheese nachos like the rest of us, she didn’t gain weight like we did. This pained her through out middle and high school.
It’s More Than Just Acceptable
I agree with the writer’s claim that we as a cultural accept being fat; however, I disagreed with it being the reason.I believe their are more issues beneath the claim.
A college friend of mine, Melanie Rose, is completing her Master’s degree and researched some reasons why black women are having problems when it comes to living a healthy lifestyle. Over dinner one night, her and I discussed what we both have found as some reasons why black women are not living a healthy lifestyle.
- Lack of Access to Healthy Foods – Can you count how many health food stores such as Wholefoods, Sprouts, and Farmers Markets are in the black neighborhoods? Even the neighborhood grocery and corner stores often do not offer healthier foods. Those that do offer healthier foods cost a lot!
- Location – In majority of black neighborhoods, there are hardly any recreation centers and gyms. The one to two rec centers are often filled with broken equipment and lack quality personal trainers and exercise classes. While these same neighborhoods may contain parks, these parks also contain a high amount of crime so safety becomes an issue.
- Education/Lack of Knowledge – Personally, I didn’t know BBQ and fried chicken were unhealthy until I was almost 18. Every Friday night in high school, I had either fried chicken or Records BBQ. Oh Records in Dallas, is the spot for the best BBQ. Trust me!
- Hair Issues – Raise your hand if your mom said this to you, “Girl don’t go outside and play too hard. You will mess up your hair and I am not doing it over again this week.” We were taught from a young age not to mess up our hair when it came to playing (a form of exercise).
- Not Important or Fun – Some people just don’t want to workout and won’t. Exercising isn’t fun for them and they don’t see it as being important.
Okay, so this is part one. I am going to chat with a few other people this week and have them to chime in on this issue.
So ladies and gentlemen (guys I know you are reading too!) give your opinion with a comment and or chime in on the survey.
Create your free online surveys with SurveyMonkey, the world’s leading questionnaire tool.
BTW: We are addressing all of these issues with solutions at our upcoming event!
NOTE: “We have received concern noting that we are using the ‘incorrect’ title for the New York Times opinion piece. We appreciate the concern and updates on this. We really appreciate all your feedback and updates. The title we are using, “Why Black Women are Fat” is the original title the Times used. Later, the it was changed. This article is now called “Black Women and Fat.” We continue to refer to the article by its original name in part for the sake of clarity, and also because the original title provoked most of the ensuing controversy and conversation about the issue.” Thank you all again!








It seems there is a lot of discussion about why black women are overweight. While I agree that it is important to look at Black people as a whole I feel like it tends to lead to over generalization. As a graduate student studying clinical psychology I lean towards focus on the individual after all a person has to want to lose weight in order to make the changes necessary. I truly believe that most people simply don’t know. While some might have a general awareness of why certain things are bad they don’t know what to eat and how to eat. At times people are dealing with psychological issues and lack the support to make changes. At times I feel like people defend their size and say they are happy the way they are as a method self preservation. I feel like this is the biggest hindrance to people truly making a change and learning about how to live a healthier lifestyle. Unless individuals can truly examine themselves and understand why being overweight or obese is detrimental to their health there will always be misinformed articles (the NYT article) that don’t address the real issues and give real solutions.
Very good points!!!
While the author touched on a series of underlying root causes, I feel the article lacks discussion on the historical and genetic perspectives of the issue of black women and weight. It’s relatively simple to assess things in their current state; it’s more complex to analyze the historical interwoven premises responsible for that same current state.
As far back as Ancient African culture has been recorded, a voluptuous woman was the woman to be desired simply because her curvature and weight represented healthy child bearing, womanhood, maturity, and generational sustainability. Voluptuous was also correlated with wealth Take a quick trip to the Dallas Museum of Art (or any museum) to peruse the African exhibit and you will immediately notice the sculptures and figurines of voluptuous African females. Not just in the African diaspora, but nearly all Eastern cultures venerated women who possessed higher percentages of body fat.
However, as a people of color ruggedly transplanted in Western culture, we have generationally been reprogrammed to aspire to the standards of beauty as handed down by European dogma and ideologies. Yet, the women of our non-melanin producing counterparts allocate millions of dollars tanning their bodies, getting butt implants, and embracing curvature: Things that women of color tend to get castigated for…… obviously something is not right in this picture.
Furthermore, people rarely address the impact of genetics when discussing “weight issues” in the black female community. Any geneticist can easily explain how specific genes are linked directly to body composition (height, weight, melanin percentage, etc). One doesn’t have to look far from the principles of Mendelian genetics to understand how genes can be passed along generations. The point I’m attempting to make is that black women, for the most part, possess genetic material that is causation for wide hips, “thickness”, and their overall voluptuousness.
I’m amazed at how the same voluptuousness that is demonized to a certain degree is the same voluptuousness that women of other races aspire to. Why do men tend to elevate Kim Kardashian, Marilyn Monroe, Scarlett Johansson, Sofia Vergara, and so many more to a status of sex symbolism?
Trust me when I say it’s not because these females won a Nobel Peace Prize or can spit Shakesperian epithets from memory.
Or better yet, what many people don’t know is that during the discovery of the “New World”, what drove many European explorers crazy were the myths and stories of new territories filled with gold and full-figured women of color. That’s correct: these cats were stimulated by the desires of possessing wealth and the idea of possessing full-figured black women.
I understand the issue of weight in the black female community. I encourage every sista I know that can drop a few lbs to hit the gym or put down the M&Ms. The author highlights several great points, but I truly feel that the historical and genetic components should also be integrated in the discussion.
Wikipedia: Calafia is a fictional warrior queen who ruled over a kingdom of Black women living on the mythical Island of California
Great history lesson!! How many degrees do you have now??
Pingback:Why Black Women are Fat Part 4 – The Thickness! Alex’s Personal Weight Loss Journey
Pingback:» Why Black Women are Fat Part 4 – The Thickness! Alex’s Personal Weight Loss Journey Strawberricurls
Pingback:Why Black Women Are Fat and How to Fix it
Pingback:Sporty Afros and Runner’s Revelation Will Be On The CW Discussing Why Black Women Are Fat
I think it is a combination of of all the above but ALSO pricing. Eating healthy is NOT cheap.Buying healthy food choices could mean an extra $50-$75 or more to your monthly grocery bill. When money is already tight this could totally blow the option for healthy choices. As I am reading your site I saw farmer market as an option and an light went off. I can remember my parents shopping at the farmers market and I totally forgot it being an option. Sites like this and education is key. We have to find a way to make healthy life choices work and utilize it. THANKS,loving the site!!!
When u study Scientology u understand that Low Tone People are making fat….and many Black People are Low Tone and are making fat…it is all in the spirit of their nature…
It’s a myth to say that being fat= a big butt. Most black women are fat with a flat butt and narrow hips..it’s really an awful sight.